🎲
Battleship·Board Games
Battleship
🌱Community
Loading OpenSourceSports…
For a longer game, use a larger shared grid and add matching ship pieces to both fleets. Establish the new coordinate labels, ship lengths, and number of shots before setup.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that adding more ships means they can place them anywhere they want on their expanded grid, leading to arguments about placement strategy rather than gameplay speed. The confusion arises because the official explanation doesn't clarify how these changes affect ship positioning rules and overall game balance.
Players may not look behind the opponent’s screen or inspect the opponent’s fleet grid.; Players must not alter ship positions after shooting begins.; Every shot and result must be recorded accurately.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they can check their opponent's grid before shooting, thinking it’s a way to gain an advantage by knowing where ships are placed. However, the true intent of this rule is to ensure fair play and prevent players from using any pre-shot information, thus maintaining the element of surprise crucial for strategy in Battleship.
Before the first shot, each player should count 17 occupied spaces and confirm that all five ship lengths are correct. Once the first coordinate has been called, no ship may be moved, rotated, exchanged, removed, or added.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they can move their ships around freely before firing a shot, thinking it's only finalized after the first hit. The actual rule is that once you've called your first coordinate, no changes to your ship placements are allowed—no matter how many shots have been fired. It’s this subtle difference in timing that causes confusion and arguments.
Each player calls five different coordinates on every turn regardless of how many ships remain. This produces a faster game and allows a player with a damaged fleet to retain full attacking power.
Why people argue about this
People often argue that they should be allowed to target fewer than five coordinates when their fleet is damaged, thinking it's fairer to conserve firepower for a tougher opponent. But actually, the fixed five-shot salvo rule ensures every turn has equal impact regardless of ship count, making each shot more valuable and keeping gameplay balanced across all players.
A player who scores a hit immediately fires again. The turn ends after a miss or after the opponent’s entire fleet is sunk.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that hitting continues as long as they score a hit, forgetting about the requirement for a miss or sinking the opponent's entire fleet to end their turn. They overlook how the official rule ensures turns are balanced and strategic, preventing endless hits from dominating game flow.
Each space of a ship can be hit only once. A ship is sunk when every space it occupies has been hit.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that hitting one space of a ship counts as sinking it if they've hit every single space on that ship at least once, which is incorrect. The confusion arises because each individual hit must be distinct; you can't "hit" the same space multiple times to count as sinking the ship.
Ships may not occupy horizontally, vertically, or diagonally adjacent spaces. The extra separation makes deduction easier because spaces surrounding a sunk ship can be eliminated.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that ships can touch diagonally adjacent spaces as long as they're not touching in a straight line, which leads to misunderstandings about what constitutes "no-touching." The confusion arises because the official rule specifically prohibits even diagonal adjacency for ships, making it harder but more precise to determine where sunk ships used to be.
Once per game, instead of firing, a player selects a predetermined search area, such as a 2-by-2 group of spaces. The opponent reports only whether at least one ship space lies in that area.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that choosing a one-time radar area is just for fun and doesn't affect gameplay, but in reality, it can significantly alter the strategy by giving opponents crucial information about where ships might be hidden, leading to heated debates over its strategic implications.
For a multi-game match, use one of these agreed scoring systems: Best-of series: Award one game win to the victor. The first player to win two games in a best-of-three series, or three games in a best-of-five series, wins the match.; Victory points: Award one point for each game won. The player w...
Why people argue about this
People often assume that in a Best-of series format like three games out of five, you simply add up all the game wins at the end to determine the winner, which can lead to confusion about how exactly points are awarded and who ultimately wins the match. The actual rule specifies awarding one point per game won, making it clearer on how to tally scores in different series lengths.
For a shorter game, use a smaller grid or fewer ships. A balanced beginner game can use an 8-by-8 grid with ships of lengths 4, 3, 3, and 2.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that reducing fleet size automatically means using a smaller grid, leading to misunderstandings about how many spaces are available for shooting across and down. The confusion arises because they overlook the fact that fewer ships can be placed in an 8x8 grid compared to more ships spread out over a larger board.
If a coordinate is spoken unclearly, the defender should ask for clarification before checking the fleet grid. Once the defender announces a result, the confirmed coordinate stands unless both players agree that a simple verbal mistake occurred.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that if they say a coordinate clearly but it's still unclear to their opponent, they can proceed with checking without asking for clarification first. But actually, the official rule states that once announced, the result stands only if both players agree there was no simple verbal mistake; otherwise, the defender must ask for confirmation before moving forward.
On each turn, a player calls several different coordinates before receiving or recording the combined results. A common method gives each player one shot for every ship still afloat.
Why people argue about this
People often think that the Salvo Play means you can only fire one shot at a time per turn, which leads to unnecessary turns when trying to hit multiple ships with just one shot each. But actually, this rule allows for firing multiple shots (a salvo) in one go, as long as they're all targeting different coordinates, regardless of the number of ships still active on the board.
Peg colors vary by set. When two colors are available, use one consistently for hits and the other for misses.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they can choose which color represents hits and which represents misses based on their preference, forgetting that consistency is key as specified in Section 2. The confusion arises because the official statement emphasizes using one color consistently for all hits and another for all misses, not allowing arbitrary selection of colors.
Before the first shot, each player should count 17 occupied spaces and confirm that all five ship lengths are correct. Once the first coordinate has been called, no ship may be moved, rotated, exchanged, removed, or added.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they can rearrange their ships after setting them up once, which leads to arguments when they find out you absolutely cannot move or rotate your ships at all once play begins. The confusion arises because this rule is so specific and rigid about setup procedures, leaving little room for interpretation or flexibility in how players initially place their ships.
After the result is announced, both players record it. The attacker places the appropriate peg on the called coordinate of the targeting grid.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that after announcing a hit or miss, they should immediately place their peg on the grid without checking if it matches the result announced by the other player. The confusion arises because the official rule actually states players record the outcome first before placing their pegs to ensure both sides agree and don't accidentally overwrite each other's moves.
There is no draw in an ordinary alternating-turn game because only one player fires at a time. The second player does not receive an equalizing final turn after the first player destroys the entire opposing fleet.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that if one player destroys all their opponent's ships first, it should result in a draw since both players have had turns firing. But actually, the official ruling states only one player fires at a time, so there can't be an equalizing final turn for the second player, thus no room for a draw exists.
Variations can make Battleship faster, more tactical, or easier for younger players. Select all house rules before ships are placed and apply them equally to both players.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that house rules must be applied only after ships are placed, thinking they can't affect gameplay before then. However, the official statement actually allows for house rules to be decided beforehand, as long as they're applied equally from the start of play, which leads to confusion about when exactly these should be implemented.
For example, a length-four Battleship may occupy B3, C3, D3, and E3 horizontally, or H5, H6, H7, and H8 vertically. It may not bend, run diagonally, extend beyond the grid, or pass through another ship.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that a ship can be placed in any direction they choose as long as it fits within the grid, which leads them to argue about whether ships can bend or extend beyond the grid boundaries. The confusion arises because the official rule explicitly states these actions are not allowed, emphasizing the importance of following the precise guidelines for ship placement.
The defender reports every successful shot as “hit” but does not announce when a ship sinks or identify its name. The attacker must infer whether a complete ship has been found.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that if their shots are silent, they're supposed to shout out every hit immediately, which leads them to think the defender should announce when a ship is sunk or reveal its name upon sinking. However, the rule actually allows for stealthy gameplay where attackers must deduce the fate of ships based on hits alone, not report each and every one.
Peg colors vary by set. When two colors are available, use one consistently for hits and the other for misses.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they can choose whichever color they prefer for hits and misses, leading to inconsistency in their gameplay. The actual rule is more precise: you must use one of the available colors consistently for all hits and another for all misses, no matter which set you're using. This subtle difference can cause arguments when players don't adhere strictly to this standard.
After the result is announced, both players record it. The attacker places the appropriate peg on the called coordinate of the targeting grid.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that they must announce their move verbally after placing it on the grid, which leads to arguments since the official rule states they should simply record it themselves once announced. The confusion arises because of a misunderstanding about what constitutes "announcing" in this context - it's not just verbal declaration but also recording the move for accuracy and fairness.
Divide players into two teams controlling one fleet each. Teammates may discuss strategy openly or quietly, as agreed, but one designated caller announces the final coordinate.
Why people argue about this
People often assume that teammates can't communicate at all during their turns, thinking it would give a team an unfair advantage by sharing coordinates before they're announced. But actually, the key is in who announces - teammates can discuss strategy freely but only one player calls out the final coordinate to ensure fair play and prevent cheating.
Set a short limit, such as 20 or 30 seconds, for choosing a coordinate. If time expires, the player loses the shot and play passes to the opponent.
Why people argue about this
People often argue that the 20-30 second limit is too short, thinking it's unfair since they sometimes need more time to think strategically, but actually the intention behind this rule is to keep the game flowing and prevent one player from dominating by taking an excessively long time to make their move.
After the final ship is sunk, both players reveal their fleet grids. They should confirm that the winning player recorded all required hits and that every ship was placed legally.
Why people argue about this
People think they're only supposed to check that their own fleet placement was correct, but actually misunderstand that they need to verify both players' grids for legal ship placements and accurate hit counts. The confusion arises because the rule doesn't explicitly state it's a joint responsibility of both players to ensure all records are spot-on.
There is no draw in an ordinary alternating-turn game because only one player fires at a time. The second player does not receive an equalizing final turn after the first player destroys the entire opposing fleet.
Why people argue about this
People think that if one player's fleet is destroyed first, the game should end in a draw since both players have had turns firing, but actually, the rule explicitly states there can be no draw because only one player fires at a time and gets to destroy the entire opposing fleet before it's considered over.